Trump Pension Rule Will Benefit Black Americans, by Council Nedd II

Put quite simply, too many black Americans are financially unprepared to retire.

Council Nedd

Council Nedd

A mix of poor economic conditions, distrust of institutions and an overall lack of planning affects all Americans. But studies show black Americans are impacted harder. So any impediment to their ability to build retirement security that is identified and yet still allowed to continue unabated is a disservice to black lives.

That’s why the Trump administration’s proposed rule clarifying the “investment duties” of certain pension plan managers matters. It addresses a clear and present financial danger in which too many fund managers are making investment decisions for the purpose of broader social justice goals rather than giving beneficiaries the best possible return on their investment.

Bottom line: Financial managers must maximize pension beneficiaries’ returns; they may not imperil those returns by investing on any other basis.

The proposed Labor Department rule addresses the current inclination of fund managers covered under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) to make risky Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG)-related investments with pension funds. It reforms potentially harmful actions to safeguard fund beneficiaries.

The rule would also prevent financially risky advocacy for a social justice agenda on someone else’s dime.

ESG investing is used to push diversity rules on corporations, pressure companies not to ally themselves with certain associations and even promote the most divisive of issues such as abortion. Doing so can put companies in fiscal peril, which makes ESG investing a luxury for those who can afford to lose.

The proposed rule would guarantee fund managers operate “solely on economic considerations” that best benefit those invested in their funds. It prohibits actions where ESG considerations are prioritized over risk-adjusted decisions maximizing investor return. In situations where a decision could be questioned, managers are required to “adequately document” their processes. And, when employees have no choice but to participate in their employer’s pension plan, ESG investing to “favor the fiduciary’s own personal political preferences” cannot be done without their approval.

Beyond political considerations alone, there are a myriad of other reasons to justify these clarifications. The most obvious is the volatility of the market due to the COVID-19 pandemic and due to social unrest that can arguably be blamed on the political environment created by “woke” ESG investing. Financial decisions must be rooted in a return on investment.

But another concern for black Americans is that these pension plans may be the only guaranteed income available for their retirement outside of Social Security – of which full benefits are currently projected to run out there within the next 17 years.

According to a study by Boston College’s Center for Retirement Research, 54% of black Americans are unprepared for retirement. That is four percent above the overall national average and six percent above their white peers. Factors contributing to this potential crisis include disparate earnings, a wealth gap and retirement plan participation.

The National Institute on Retirement Security did report that 54% of black employees have access to retirement plans through their employer, including defined benefit plans. And black Americans make up a larger portion of the unionized – and often pensioned – workforce.

Pension plans could be the best bet for black retirement security. This locked-away benefit is also valuable in overcoming an inherited problem that EFC Wealth Management CEO Cory Chapman identified as black Americans being “bad savers.” Chapman told the Atlanta Voicethat “we were taught by our grandparents that we couldn’t trust banks.” Pension plans can help.

But pensions can only help if they have proper stewardship. That’s the aim of the new Trump administration rule.

By holding pension fund managers to the logical expectation that they will make the most profitable moves for their investors, it can help all Americans – and especially black Americans, as is our focus – enjoy their golden years.


Project 21 Co-Chairman Council Nedd II, co-chairman of the Project 21 black leadership network, is a Pennsylvania State Constable and rector of St. Alban’s Anglican Church in State College, Pennsylvania. This was originally published by Issues & Insights.

New Visions Commentaries reflect the views of their author, and not necessarily those of Project 21, other Project 21 members, or the National Center for Public Policy Research, its board or staff.

Project 21, a leading voice of black conservatives for over 25 years, is sponsored by the National Center for Public Policy Research. Its members have been quoted, interviewed or published over 40,000 times since the program was created in 1992. Contributions to the National Center are tax-deductible and greatly appreciated, and may be earmarked exclusively for the use of Project 21.